
No tickets. No accidents. No claims. And your car insurance quote still came back higher than you expected.
In a lot of these cases, your driving has nothing to do with it. The reason is a number most people have never seen: your credit-based insurance score. Below is how it works, what Georgia law lets carriers do with it, and what you can do about it.
What an insurance score is (and isn't)
An insurance score is built from the information on your credit report, but it isn't the score your mortgage lender or car dealer looks at. According to the National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC), a traditional credit score predicts whether you'll repay a loan. An insurance score estimates how likely you are to file a claim.
Georgia law defines it the same way. An insurance score is a number based in whole or in part on credit information "for the purposes of predicting the future insurance loss exposure" of a driver or homeowner (O.C.G.A. § 33-24-90).
What goes into it
Several companies build insurance scores for carriers. Here is the general weighting for FICO's model, from the NAIC's consumer guide:
- Payment history: 40%
- Outstanding debt: 30%
- Length of credit history: 15%
- Pursuit of new credit: 10%
- Credit mix: 5%
Why carriers use it
Carriers say credit helps them predict claims. Progressive says its own data shows customers with the worst insurance scores are twice as likely to have an accident or claim as customers with the best scores. FICO estimates that about 95% of auto insurers use these scores in states that allow it.
That's the industry's side of it. The NAIC notes that regulators and consumer advocates still question whether the scores fully reflect risk, especially after an illness or job loss that hurts credit but doesn't make anyone a worse driver.
Credit is also only one piece of the price. The NAIC lists claims history, driving record, location, coverage limits, and deductibles as other common inputs, so your clean record still counts.
What Georgia allows and what it limits
Georgia lets insurers use insurance scores in rating and underwriting, but only within the rules in O.C.G.A. §§ 33-24-90 through 33-24-98. Those rules cover "personal insurance," which includes private passenger auto and homeowners policies.
What a carrier has to tell you
- A carrier that uses credit has to say so on the application or when the application is taken (§ 33-24-93).
- Under Georgia law, an "adverse action" includes a denial, a cancellation, or an increase in any charge. If credit information leads to one, the carrier has to notify you and list up to four main reasons. Vague phrases like "poor credit history" aren't enough (§ 33-24-94).
What a carrier can't do
Under O.C.G.A. § 33-24-91, a carrier that uses credit cannot:
- Deny, cancel, or nonrenew a personal policy based solely on credit information.
- Set your renewal rate based solely on credit information.
- Build the score using your income, gender, race, address, ZIP code, ethnic group, religion, marital status, or nationality.
- Take adverse action just because you don't have a credit card.
- Count medical collection accounts or insurance-related inquiries against you.
- Count several mortgage or auto loan inquiries made within 30 days as more than one inquiry.
If you're disputing an item on your credit report, the carrier must either leave it out or treat it as neutral for 45 days after the dispute is filed.
Carriers file their scoring models with the Insurance Commissioner, and Georgia law treats those filings as trade secrets that aren't public. That means I can't tell you exactly how much weight any one carrier puts on credit.
The federal notice, too
Federal law has its own rules under the Fair Credit Reporting Act. When a decision is based even partly on a credit report, Section 615(a) requires the company to give you the credit bureau's name and contact information and a statement that the bureau didn't make the decision.
The company also has to tell you about your right to a free report and to dispute errors. The CFPB says you must request that free report within 60 days of getting the notice.
What you can actually do about it
1. Pull your credit reports for free
You can get a free report from Equifax, Experian, and TransUnion once a week at AnnualCreditReport.com. Look for accounts you don't recognize, late payments that weren't late, or old debts that should be gone.
If you find a mistake, the CFPB recommends disputing it with the credit bureau first, in writing, and then with the company that reported it.
2. Ask your carrier to re-rate you at renewal
In Georgia, the carrier must re-underwrite and re-rate your policy on request at annual renewal, using a new credit report or score. It doesn't have to do this more than once every 12 months.
Before you ask, know two things:
- The carrier has to warn you that a re-rate could raise your rate, lower it, lead to nonrenewal, or change nothing.
- There are exceptions. For example, a carrier doesn't have to pull new credit if you're already in its best-priced tier or if it didn't use credit when it first wrote your policy.
I'd only ask for this if your credit has clearly improved since you bought the policy. If it hasn't, I'd leave it alone.
3. Mention a major life event
The NAIC says many insurers will reconsider a premium change if your credit took a hit from something like a catastrophic event, job loss, or serious illness. I didn't find a Georgia statute that requires this. It's worth asking, but don't count on it.
4. Have an independent agent shop it
Carriers don't all use the same score, and they don't all blend it with their other rating factors the same way. That's one reason the same driver can get very different prices from one company to the next. Georgia's Insurance Commissioner recommends that you shop around and give each company the same information so the quotes are actually comparable.
That's the part we can do for you. As an independent agent, we can compare several carriers side by side with the same coverage, so you aren't filling out form after form.
Want a second look at your quote?
If your rate jumped at renewal and nobody could tell you why, or your credit has improved since you last shopped, we'd be happy to take a look. We can't promise a lower price, and sometimes the honest answer is that your current carrier is still the best option.
Call us at 404-850-7501 or reach out through www.flex-ins.com.
This is general information, not legal or coverage advice. Individual policies, carriers, and situations vary.
Sources
- NAIC, Credit-Based Insurance Scores
- NAIC, Consumer Insight: Credit-Based Insurance Scores Aren't the Same as a Credit Score
- Official Code of Georgia, § 33-24-90, § 33-24-91, § 33-24-92, § 33-24-93, § 33-24-94, § 33-24-95, § 33-24-98 (via Justia)
- Georgia Office of Commissioner of Insurance and Safety Fire, Auto Insurance
- Fair Credit Reporting Act, Section 615 (15 U.S.C. 1681m) (via Federal Reserve)
- CFPB, How do I get a free copy of my credit reports?
- CFPB, How do I dispute an error on my credit report?
